Sutton Place Books Sutton Place Books

Let Me Try Again: Funniest Book of the Year?

DeborahGoldberg • January 13, 2025

I just finished Matthew Davis’s *Let Me Try Again*, and I can't stop laughing. It's sharp, hilarious, and surprisingly heartfelt. What do you all think? Is Ross the best (or most annoying) protagonist of the year?

Discussion (7 Comments)

RachelBernstein • 1/13/2025

I couldn't agree more! At first, I found Ross insufferable. His arrogance and endless schemes made me roll my eyes. But by the middle of the book, I was completely on his side. Davis does an incredible job of peeling back his bravado to reveal someone deeply vulnerable. This might be the best book I've read all year.

JonahLevine • 1/13/2025

Same here! Ross's antics were so over the top, but I think that was the point. The way Davis balances humor and emotional depth is masterful. I loved every moment, even when I wanted to throttle Ross.

AnnaCohen • 1/13/2025

Exactly! At first, I was like, 'This guy is the worst.' But then I started rooting for him. The relationship with his sister added so much heart to the story. It’s rare to find a book that makes you laugh and cry like this one did.

MichaelGoldstein • 1/13/2025

I’m a huge fan of *Seinfeld* and *Curb Your Enthusiasm*, and this book felt like it was written for people like me. Ross is such a Larry David type—neurotic, self-centered, but ultimately endearing. I haven’t laughed this much at a book in years.

SaraFeldman • 1/13/2025

YES! The humor was spot on, but I also loved how Davis didn’t shy away from exploring Ross’s grief. The balance between comedy and tragedy was perfect. This book stayed with me long after I finished it.

NathanShapiro • 1/13/2025

I’ve already recommended this book to half a dozen people. It’s rare to find a debut that’s this funny and this well-written. Ross’s schemes were ridiculous, but they felt so true to life. And that ending—perfect.

EliStein • 1/13/2025

Agreed. I think Davis is the first great Jewish writer of Gen Z. His ability to weave cultural references, humor, and emotional depth into a single story is remarkable. Ross is unforgettable.